A reader writes: - Estonian World Review

A reader writes: (1)

Archived Articles | 28 Jan 2005 | Martin PuhvelEWR

In an informative and thoughtful article, “Estonians ask: “who's a fascist? (III)”, (“Estonian Life” Nov. 26, 2004) Laas Leivat refers to the conclusion of the International Commission for the Investigation of Crimes against Humanity that the 36th Estonian Police Battalion “participated on August 7, 1942, in the gathering together and shooting of Jews in the town of Novogrudok in Belarus.”

I think it worth noting that this conclusion, included in a lengthy report on the three occupations of Estonia — starting in 1940 — issued in 2002 by the above-mentioned body (commissioned by President Meri in 1998), was subsequently contradicted by the findings of the Estonian Security Police, whose Director Jüri Pihl declared on July 22, 2002, in answer to a request by Efraim Zuroff of the Wiesenthal Center that the Police investigate a number of members of the Battalion, that there was no evidence that any of the men on Mr. Zuroff's list or any other member of this unit participated in any crimes.

One may note that the Commission's conclusion in this matter was based essentially on “records of post-war Soviet era trials.” The lack of credibility of such “evidence” is, I think, obvious, at least to Estonians.

(The Commission's report is available on the Internet at www.historycommission.ee as is the controversy surrounding the allegation in question — the latter under the heading “36th Estonian Police Battalion.”)

Viimased kommentaarid

Kommentaarid on kirjutatud EWR lugejate poolt. Nende sisu ei pruugi ühtida EWR toimetuse seisukohtadega.

Carol Aun06 Feb 2005 19:28

Does ANYONE believe post-war Soviet trials? or any Soviet documention? That the Police Battalion were involved, by Soviet lights only, is patently absurd.

Has anyone bothered to check Estonian records? if they still exist? or interview survivors? their families? family records?

I am disgusted.

Loe kõiki kommentaare (1)

Archived Articles

The reverberations of Soviet totalitarianism in Finland: Sympathies and contradictions (II) (1)
Translated from Imbi Paju’s article in “Maailma Vaade” (View of the World).

This year 70 years have passed since the signing of the ...

How to Liberate an Economy
Entrepreneurs understand the importance of freedom in the workplace

Guy Sorman, TCS Daily

Brian Carney and Isaac Getz's Freedom, Inc. is a ...

Lessons from Estonia: Protecting the West from a computer attack
Väino Reinart, National Post, October 22, 2009

The cyber attacks carried out against Estonia in the spring of 2007 served as a wake-up call about ...

Opening statement by Mark Carney Governor of the Bank of Canada Press conference following the release of the Monetary Policy Report 22 October 2009
Good morning. Paul and I are pleased to be here with you today to discuss the October Monetary Policy Report, which we published this morning.

...

Welcome home
It is high time to abolish the concept of ethnic minorities
Europe.view column, Oct 22nd 2009, from Economist.com

Should the Polish ethnic ...

Moscow Patriarchate’s efforts to subordinate ‘alternative Orthodox’ undercut Russia’s future, Regelson says (2)
VIENNA, October 22 – The Moscow Patriarchate’s drive to subordinate all independent Orthodox bishops and believers to its own power vertical, an ...